Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming various industries, including education. Its integration into learning environments has transformed how students and educators interact with educational content. Tools like ChatGPT and Gemini offer personalised, responsive feedback, gaining popularity among students preparing for significant exams like the HSC. However, it’s crucial to weigh the benefits and potential risks of incorporating AI into your study routine.
The Risks of Using AI in Education
Biased and Incorrect Information
AI systems, such as ChatGPT, are only as good as the data they were trained on. If this data contains biases, the AI can inadvertently perpetuate them, reinforcing social inequalities. Moreover, AI tools have data limitations. For instance, ChatGPT’s knowledge extends only up to September 2023, potentially leaving it outdated regarding the latest educational content or current curriculum specifics.
Blurring the Lines of Academic Integrity
The use of AI in education raises complex issues around academic integrity. Detecting AI-generated content is becoming more sophisticated, and students risk severe penalties if they use AI without proper disclosure. For example, Australian universities often require assignments to be submitted through plagiarism detection software like Turnitin. High school students must develop good practices that will align with these future academic standards.
Overdependence on Technology
Relying too much on AI can hinder the development of critical skills such as independent thought, problem-solving, and deep understanding of material. These skills are vital for both academic success and professional life. Students overly dependent on AI may struggle with complex challenges requiring autonomous thinking and a comprehensive grasp of their studies.
Cognitive Skills at Risk
Using AI excessively can impair cognitive functions like memory and concentration. Over-reliance on AI tools can diminish students’ ability to recall information and think critically, essential skills for exam success. Academic studies have shown that heavy AI use, particularly with tools like ChatGPT, can lead to reduced critical thinking and memory retention.
Difficulty Managing Sources
While AI tools can streamline research and note-taking, they also pose challenges in tracking the origins of data. Unlike traditional methods where references are manually logged, AI-generated summaries often lack clear citations. This can obscure the traceability of factual data and quotes, complicating the verification of information.
Limited Effectiveness in High-Stakes Situations
A recent experiment by 9news.com.au revealed limitations of AI in academic settings. When asked to produce essays for the 2022 HSC English exam, ChatGPT’s outputs were rated below a passing grade by HSC teachers. This indicates that while AI can assist with drafting and basic guidance, it may not fully capture the nuances required for high-level academic performance.
Choosing the Right AI for HSC Success
Dodie.ai: A Tailored Approach to HSC English
Dodie.ai, designed by top NSW HSC English performers, offers tailored support specifically for HSC students. Unlike broader AI platforms, Dodie focuses on enhancing students’ writing by providing feedback on their original work, much like a supportive teacher or tutor. Dodie understands the intricacies of prescribed texts, helping students significantly improve their writing skills.
The Balanced Approach to Using AI in Education
AI can offer substantial benefits at various educational levels, providing customised learning aids and efficient study tools. However, the associated risks are significant and must be managed thoughtfully. Students, educators, and developers should aim to use AI as a complementary tool that enhances learning without undermining the essential human aspects of education.
For additional guidance and support, contact Pre Uni College Digital at (02) 8311 0885, email us at info@preunicollegedigital.com.au, or inquire about finding tutors near you. Start early, stay organised, and balance your study with well-deserved breaks to achieve your best results.
